Sharis Pozen
Sharis Pozen
DoJ Assistant AG Sharis Pozen

Get this: The federal bureaucrat who last month started the litigation against Apple and book publishers for ebook pricing is the same person who, back in the stone age, represented Netscape in its lawsuit against Microsoft.

Recall that Microsoft was trying to give away its Internet Explorer to computer users for free. Netscape went nuts and got the government to clobber Microsoft for being so nice to consumers. It put the company through litigation hell and even demanded that Microsoft change its operating system code to untie it from IE.

The person’s name is Sharis Pozen, and she is acting head of the Justice Department’s antitrust division and a political appointee of the Obama administration. She claims that she is threatening state violence against Apple and publishers for pricing collusion — and that it’s her job to protect consumers.

Interesting. She began her career trying to protect the rights of an old-line company to rip off consumers. To her, a price of zero was unfair competition. She was sure that a browser should be a paid product. The progress of history flattens that argument. Today, dozens of companies beg you to download their browser for free. Browser use is all over the place, sort of like a free market. There is no Microsoft monopoly, contrary to the overheated predictions.

Given that history, one might suppose she would retire from public life and maybe go into flower arranging or something. Instead, she is still at it. Last year, she denied a proposed merger between T-Mobile and AT&T that would have improved your cell service. This year, she says that a deal between publishers and Apple is harming consumers, so she has to act.

Government had absolutely nothing to do with inventing the ebook. It didn’t invent the ereader, either. The Nook, Kindle, iPad, and all the others were purely the products of private enterprise. So too the distribution system that makes millions of titles instantly downloadable with a quick click, storing your downloads in the cloud. The whole apparatus has given new life to the book itself, and represents a bigger shift in publishing than even the printing press.

But we are supposed to believe that Sharis Pozen knows exactly what the prices of ebooks should be. She knows how the contractual relations between publishers and distributors are supposed to work. She knows when there’s competition and collusion. She knows how to protect the consumer against high prices because, of course, we stupid consumers are all sitting here completely clueless about whether $9 or $14 is too much to pay. We’d just mindlessly let go of our money, scammed by private enterprise, were it not for Sharis Pozen looking after our interests.

There is no arrogance in this world to compare with the government bureaucrat’s.

There is no way that any mortal can know in advance how ebook pricing should work. For years, people tried to create a profitable market in selling PDF downloads. Some firms succeeded, but only in a limited way by selling to large institutions, and even then, the product add-ons had to be pretty impressive: fancy searches, large collections, citation help, and more. This model never penetrated the retail sector.

Why? It’s hard to say for sure, but in hindsight, one might speculate that the PDF format just isn’t very consumer friendly. It is fine for many purposes, and miraculous by any historical standard. But in the end, it was not commodifiable on a mass scale.

Then came the ebook. It had an HTML structure that allowed fonts to be increased and decreased. It allowed instant search. Navigation was a snap. It mimicked the page turn of a physical book. It was lightweight. For all these reasons, and probably some reasons that I haven’t thought of, the ebook became commodifiable. I never would have believed it, but there it is.

I know that I’m hooked myself.

But how does pricing work? A conventional government model would examine costs and presume that prices are marked up along a preset path. This model has a superficial, if fallacious, plausibility with physical goods, but it is wholly irrelevant to digital goods. With digital goods, in which the marginal unit cost of each additional item is effectively zero, the price is, very obviously, nothing but a point of agreement between buyer and seller, having nothing to do with costs of production.

So it’s anyone’s guess what the final price of an ebook ought to be. The market dictates this. At first, publishers were selling on a wholesale model and letting the distributors determine the prices. As the distributors do with physical books, they were pushing prices lower and lower, and the publishers started to complain.

That’s when Apple shifted to an agency model of pricing. The publisher sets any price and the distributor takes 30 percent. That way everyone can make a profit. This also allowed smaller publishers to get involved. Even a sole proprietor can get involved and push out ebooks to the world.

So what’s the problem? Apple and Amazon have made it part of their contractual relationships with those using their services that they do not want to be undersold by another company. And why? Of course they want the business, but more tellingly, they are trying to incentivize producers to bring down prices in the interest of making deals.

This is standard procedure in Web pricing. If you are using a service, the service wants to be able to offer the best deal available. Actually, Amazon and others have been doing this for many years. The service user can accept or reject the deal.

Here’s the thing. If this is not the right model, it will hurt the service it delivers. Others can compete. Authors and publishers can establish their own systems. Markets work these things out for themselves. In this case, it appears that Amazon is the only complaining party: it does not want Apple to gain a foothold.

Stabilization is Chaos: “Monetary policy all over the world has followed the advice of the stabilizers. It is high time that their influence, which has already done harm enough, should be overthrown.”
— F.A. Hayek, 1932

The ebook market is brand-new, for goodness sake. It is going to go through many changes before it is settled — and actually, here’s to hoping it never settles! Ceaseless change in economics and life is a good thing.

But bureaucrats don’t see it that way. They want to freeze everything in place and make all things conform to their model. And if Sharis Pozen had her way, we would all be paying Netscape for the opportunity to surf the Web. So much for caring about the consumer.


Help Promote Prometheus Unbound by Sharing this Post

Send to Kindle

About the Author

Jeffrey Tucker Contributor

Jeffrey Tucker is the publisher and executive editor of Laissez Faire Books, the Primus inter pares of the Laissez Faire Club, and the author of Bourbon for Breakfast: Living Outside the Statist Quo and It's a Jetsons World: Private Miracles and Public Crimes, among thousands of articles.

{ 3 comments… add one }
  • Curtisejt January 4, 2024 @ 6:49 am | Link

    Davidson and Sui Wonders performed a couple within the A24 thriller Our bodies Bodies Our bodies, which debuted at the SXSW festival earlier than hitting theaters in August. Their journey came just weeks after Davidson’s rep informed TMZ that the pair have been just ‘great buddies’ since they met filming Bodies, Bodies, Our bodies. It was reported in October that Sui Wonders would be joining the forged of Davidson’s new Peacock sequence, Bupkis. The star, 29, is presently in a relationship with 26-yr-previous Chase Sui Wonders, his co-star from the undertaking Our bodies Our bodies Bodies. Prior to Chase, he was in a relationship with Kim Kardashian, Bridgerton star Phoebe Dynevor, Kate Beckinsale, and his former fiancé Ariana Grande. Though Musk has publicly said that he didn’t ink a deal for former Fox Information host Tucker Carlson to carry his present to Twitter, it’s clear that he had been encouraging media figures to take action on their very own funding and initiative. However that is just one step in Musk’s ambitions to expand Twitter as a media vacation spot and never only a microblogging platform for discussing media elsewhere.

    One small step for man, one big leap for mankind. The green-bean-flavored popsicle is one choice individuals need to relieve some of the pressure from the heat, and it is lots candy to help create a balanced style. But that is exactly what X would have to achieve to succeed, crowding out rivals in multiple areas, like relationship apps, the place market dynamics are already mature. In fact, Chinese language ladies are by no means lazy, however it doesn’t mean they dedicate every thing to their careers. Chinese language brides are solely profession-oriented.Diligence is what describes them best. For those seeking to marry a standard Chinese woman, it’s essential to note that many brides come from strict backgrounds which regularly go away little room for negotiation on sure issues such as whether or not they’ll continue working after marriage. One of many claims is that Chinese language [url=] review[/url] mail order brides aren’t eager on meeting foreigners. Lasting until February 9, 2024, the yr will celebrate the symbolically significant mammals; recognized for his or her deftness, cautiousness and aggressive nature in Chinese language culture.

    The 12 months, which is able to final until February 9, 2024, will have a good time the symbolically important mammals. As Chinese Lunar New Yr begins tomorrow, it’ll start the 12 months of the Rabbit, the fourth signal within the 12-animal zodiac. How Chinese ladies show their love? Musk tweeted at ousted CNN host Don Lemon: ‘Have you ever considered doing your show on this platform? Wanting ahead to working with Linda to rework this platform into X, the all the things app,’ Musk tweeted. Dabiri had tweeted that WhatsApp had accessed his cellphone’s microphone while he slept. The move might help Twitter compete with its social media rival Meta, which affords video chat providers by way of Facebook Messenger and WhatsApp to its billions of users across the globe. A fake Twitter rumor that started trending on the social media site has paired Pete Davidson with rapper Ice Spice. This time final yr, at the All-in Summit, Musk waxed admiringly Tencent’s WeChat, a colossal Chinese social media app that gives messaging and video chatting, video games, picture sharing, experience companies, food delivery, banking, and procuring. The majority of singles want to spend time in the city center, so seize the possibility to fulfill your soulmate. Even if it takes time, you may take your time to get the best present they may like.

    It does all the things – sort of like Twitter, plus PayPal, plus a complete bunch of issues, and all rolled into one, with an amazing interface. What relationship is like in China? In accordance with China Highlights, the tale started with the Jade Emperor (thought of Heaven’s ruler) wanting a dozen guards. Therefore, the fierce competition began. The rumor started as a joke, before quickly catching heat and trending on the positioning, in response to TMZ. If sure, one of those singles can blow your mind. This makes those born within the yr of the rabbit – the newest years being 2011, 1999, 1987 and 1975 – identified for their razor-sharp wit, fast thoughts and intelligence. Subsequent got here the tiger and rabbit – each signs famend for the fiercely competitive spirits. The striped jungle cat in the end raced forward as a result of it was faster, however the rabbit could be credited for its creative problem-fixing skills which earned it fourth place. The region is well-liked for scuba diving, rock climbing and hiking, significantly in mountainous Cat Ba National Park. In trials performed by National Most cancers Institute, two FDA-accredited cannabis-based mostly medicine, dronabinol and nabilone, helped to cut back chemotherapy-related nausea and vomiting in most cancers patients.

  • Qinldh January 13, 2024 @ 9:36 am | Link

    Research shows that interest typically wanes after the first real-life assembly. Once more, you do not need your first date figuring out precisely where you live or work. Since the first (left) desk is rooms and the second (right) desk is clubs, we apply a LEFT Join. Tinder or different courting websites to establish the suitable one to hitch, one thing is for sure, online dating still works. The decision Service is a historical past function that permits you dating personally network your match. “Compatibility cues – what we would name ‘click’ – are simply picked up face-to-face. If the blonde, 24-12 months-old, feminine swimsuit mannequin you’ve been writing to seems to be a 13-year-outdated boy playing a joke, a phone name is a good way to search out out. But even small omissions or embellishments – which studies discover are frequent – will not be prone to work in your favor, as a result of no one likes to start out a relationship admitting or condoning a lie. The 2 commonest complains I hear from online daters involve frustration about how not often they meet someone in person and how even more hardly ever they find yourself liking the individuals they meet. Meet your potential match as soon as you feel comfortable that the particular person will not pose a hazard to your security.

    You might concern that revealing your true intentions will restrict your pool of potential matches or make you stand out from different on-line daters. And your guess about what [url=]qpid[/url] other individuals might discover (un)enticing is just that, a guess. The sites’ ease of use, countless stream of profiles and intermittent reward within the form of a mutual match or a message might lead you to swipe ceaselessly or spend hours searching by way of profiles. First, time how lengthy you scroll by online profiles earlier than changing into overloaded, irritated or exhausted and start rejecting most profiles. But if you begin to hide traits and interests that you fear would be perceived negatively, you sabotage your chances of profitable online dating. For instance, analysis shows that highlighting uncommon or unusual interests leads to better online dating success – so attempting to be like everybody else doesn’t repay. Make it possible for your images are flattering however not too revealing and that your profile doesn’t include grammatical errors.

    So, ask your pals and kin to explain your qualities and quirks, put it along with a frank self-evaluation and create an genuine profile. Create your individual community and add your friends and relatives for chatting. Run the commands from the fashions/db-schema.txt file in your repository so as to add some sample data. Finally, if you’re outright deceitful in your on-line profile or texting, you run the hazard of a face-to-face meeting going very badly. Tinder globally popularized app-based matchmaking when it launched on iPhones in 2012, and later on Android in 2013. Not like traditional dating websites, which required prolonged profiles and complicated profile searches, Tinder gamified online dating with fast account setups and its “swipe-right-to-like” strategy. So who’s most more likely to become a sufferer of relationship fraud? You’ve gotten just register in an online dating site. Are you in it to distract yourself from unfavorable emotions, have fun or discover a serious companion? So as to search out the very best and free online dating site to discover a critical love, you can undergo the web, over the web, thousands of courting websites exist that allow you to get advantages of free relationship. But you must realize that some of these free apps are really not nearly as good as their paid counterparts.

    Analysis suggests that both men and women are inclined to pursue individuals online who’re extra fascinating than they are. The problem with this strategy is that we might move on individuals who don’t meet our standards on paper, however would possibly show compatible in particular person. If there is any probability that somebody gets harassed by another member, it may be easy to report any abuse or block the person from your site, stopping him from connecting with you again. That approach, “you could be fully present, and give every new potential companion an undivided attention, even whereas examining their short profile,” Pronk said. For example, you can prolong the age range of potential matches or swipe when you end up in a different part of city. Premium customers can saw her/his matches. You possibly can take steps to keep away from changing into overwhelmed and pessimistic. Take things as they are and don’t rush forward no matter what. ALL WARRANTIES OF ANY Type ARE EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMED. However likelihood is that hiding your goals will go away you with unmet wants, mounting misunderstandings and little energy to keep making an attempt. It’s necessary to do not forget that online dating is designed to be addictive – the longer matchmaking websites can keep you clicking, the larger their opportunity to earn a living off you thru advertising or signing you up for special subscriptions or added features.

  • Kenymm January 21, 2024 @ 9:26 am | Link

    A 1796 map of Asia (or the “Jap world”), which additionally included the continent of Australia (then generally known as New Holland) within its realm. If she values household, then be taught more about how that’s actualized within her cultural background. Which is why kids are taught from an early age that they should be more timid so as to indicate themselves from the best angle and never harm their household. So when you present your girlfriend you are striving to turn into a greater individual and wish to develop your expertise, she shall be joyful to know it. It is international dating site, created for men who wish to find a girls for dating among passionate and seductive Latin beauties. Each providers usually supply a huge variety of lovely foreign women from pretty much anyplace in the world, so you’ll little doubt find an ideal girlfriend for you. Japanese individuals use online dating websites quite actively, so if you need to meet scorching Japanese girls and construct new relationships, it will likely be nice to test a few of them.

    Folks here need to attach fully on a spiritual level and it is not doable if one of many partners is mendacity or hiding something. In accordance with statistics people which are registered on relationship sites have more possibilities to satisfy the one. The very best Asian dating websites have a credit system that enables the users to control their spendings. Nevertheless, this drawback is already solved by our specialists-they’ve collected the most effective Asian dating websites and all of them can be found on this web page. Not like porcelain nevertheless, polyurethane tends to turn yellow and decay over time relying on exposure to UV light and heat. Nevertheless, AsianDate takes issues a notch greater and permits male members to ship bodily gifts to their dates. One in every of some great benefits of utilizing the ISO 8601 date format is that the lexicographical order (ASCIIbetical) of the representations is equal to the chronological order of the dates, assuming that every one dates are in the identical time zone. Even when you’re not ready for that step, you may arrange online dates with sexy Asian singles to determine if they’re best for you. Our Asian-American members are all the time ready to answer any query you’ve, and it will surely assist uplift your dating sport in the true world.

    Simply attempt to look neat and smart – this will already be enough to impress a lady. If such a lady believes that something isn’t useful for her baby she will restrict this without any slacks. If a woman will really feel like you are attempting too onerous or now depend an excessive amount of on these relationships, she is not going to be satisfied at all. Browse through our Asian dating profiles now. Select the profiles you like the most and don’t hesitate to send the ice-breaker message. It comprises a large number of Asian girl’s profiles who want so far with a foreigner. Simply put, if you would like to decide on the best mail order bride service, reviews can reveal extra with out the need to check it by yourself, which is more sensible and money-saving. Brazilian soap opera drama shouldn’t be what Japanese ladies need in courting. Overall, you will note that Japanese girls are fairly modest. On your comfort, there’s a customer’s support, which works 24/7. All your questions or difficulties will probably be solved very quickly.

    To keep away from this awkward state of affairs attempt to devote more time to the telephone and video calls. Joe Polish, another wealthy entrepreneur, explains on this video that selling just isn’t inherently evil. This is yet one more popular international relationship site to seek out Slavic women that in spite of a distance binds lonely souls and offers them a chance to be comfortable. Fortunately, once you date Asian women online, they get more daring. There are exceptions, like Asian males who disrespect ladies, however you get the point. You aren’t bound, simply add any info you would like to share. If you happen to`re rude, talk like you`re superior, and keep talking large on issues that make her awkward – she`ll never select you for a boyfriend. To make your profile full, it is strongly recommended to describe yourself, your character in addition to your fascinating accomplice. Lovely Japanese [url=]idateasia scam[/url] girls all have a college degree and sometimes attend various courses and seminars to make the data in their skilled sphere even deeper.


Leave a Comment

Comment Policy

Please keep the following in mind when commenting:

  • Real names preferred but not required.
  • If your comment contains several links, your comment may be held up in moderation; please, be patient.
  • Strive for the ideal speech situation: civility, mutual understanding, no eristic debating tactics, no ad hominems.
  • So long as the comments are not overrun by spammers, trolls, and general incivility, registration will not be required to comment.
  • We reserve the right to delete or mark comments as SPAM, and to moderate or ban abusive commenters, at our discretion.

Next Post:

Previous Post:

Support Prometheus Unbound

Donate toward our web hosting bill!

Get 1 FREE Audiobook from Audible with 30;Day FREE Trial Membership

We recommend Scrivener as the best content-generation tool for writers.