Cloud Atlas
Cloud Atlas

Cloud Atlas, a movie based on the novel of the same name, is a bundle of stories with interconnecting threads meant to form a greater pattern, a message to the viewer. We are all in this together, we conclude by the movie’s end. Sometimes we are nice to each other, and sometimes we are not, but either way our actions resonate into the future, even as they were partly shaped by actions from the past that resonated into the present. The filmmakers are successful in creating this pattern, but as a piece of entertainment and a storytelling vehicle, the movie itself achieves only limited success.

Each story of the larger tale is engaging by itself. That is, the scenario created is interesting enough and worthy of its own movie. The scenes are shot well, and thoughtfully, and the worlds, ranging from far in the past to far in the future, are imaginative conceptions where many other stories might take place. Given this format, it is difficult to summarize the film, which is just as well because watching it becomes more of an exercise in identifying themes and spotting parallels than in following a plot.

The cutting between stories is done in such a way as to prevent momentum from accruing. While I have read many good books that switched between multiple characters to good effect, these books had the characters as part of the same story, so that an advance in the plot of one character’s story had immediate and important ramifications for the other characters, wherever they were in their story arcs. Each chapter usually had a beginning, middle, and end, as if it were its own short story, and finished with some sort of hook to make you regret leaving that character.

In Cloud Atlas, a character in one tale might compose music that another character hears decades later, but the connection is only important for the theme; it has no bearing on the obstacles to be overcome in the endeavor to reach a goal. With only a handful of exceptions, the characters in later times are not even aware of the ones who anteceded them. Imagine taking scenes from Amistad, Blade Runner, Star Wars, Miller’s Crossing, and Three Days of the Condor and mixing them together into one film. As far as the plot goes, this is almost exactly how isolated each story is from the others, how little they have to do with one another.

This problem is exacerbated by the differences in tone of the different pieces. One of the strands of story is comical, almost farcical. Another is dark with hints of terror, while a third is a suspenseful mystery. It is jarring enough to cut between them while disregarding plot rhythm, but we must endure radical and abrupt tonal shifts as well.

Thematically, it is a different story, and the themes and parallels are what drive the editing. Two characters are shown to be in a similar position, and the editor cuts back and forth between them as they navigate their circumstances, separated by time but connected by their humanity. The parallel is what they want us to see, and if they leave for a third perspective at a propitious time for the plot, it is merely by happenstance. They are as likely to cut away at an awkward moment pacing-wise, and one senses that this does not concern them.

It is a unique but not altogether satisfactory reversal. A movie is usually about the plot and characters; everything else must be adjusted to accommodate them. Cloud Atlas is about the theme and the story is cut up to accommodate that concern. While I was not unmoved by the skill with which they developed their themes, I was never fully convinced by that approach, for the same reason I might admire a chef’s sauce but wonder why he filled a bowl with it and sprinkled some meat on top.

The theme itself I find partially unconvincing. We are indeed connected in a way, and our actions, good and bad, have repercussions so let’s all be nice to each other. However, from the observable facts that we can exert influence on each other, even across time, and are all part of the same human story, the filmmakers draw the conclusion that we are one. A virtuoso composer, astonished at the musical ideas that his apprentice has turned into a sextet, The Cloud Atlas Sextet, claims that the apprentice must have absorbed the ideas from him, the composer. A sextet like that, he claims, could never be the result of a man, but can be claimed by all of us. The apprentice agrees with him.

This is nothing but nonsense. Cloud Atlas seeks to discredit the idea of a separate identity. It does not follow from the composer’s influence on the apprentice that he can claim partial authorship of a work he was not even aware was in existence as it was being composed. Unless the work is truly copied, it is the work of the apprentice and merely influenced by the composer. It is telling, I think, that writers and directors are able to show our influences on each other without having to state them, but when it comes time to argue that we are not merely influential to each other, but are actually part of the same whole, they must resort to making the argument explicit. They cannot show it, because it simply is not true.

There is nothing wrong with a character explicitly stating something in a work, but only as a sort of summary of the things the work itself has been demonstrating all along. At no point is anything like a great human oneness established, so when the composer makes the claim, or a slave girl makes a plea over the radio to all human kind along the same lines, it seems almost to come out of nowhere.

The many roles of Hugo Weaving.
The many roles of Hugo Weaving.

Though there are many roles in the film, there are comparatively few actors because each actor performs in various roles throughout. This is a wise move in that it supports the notions the filmmakers are trying to get across, even if some of the notions are silly, but it has gotten them into a bit of trouble with the PC crowd. Some characters, you see, are made up to be of a different race, and this simply must be racist.

This is about as absurd as the notion of the great human oneness. Each and every human being, no matter the race, gender, or sexual orientation, is treated with dignity as a member of the species. This is not to say that all the characters are sympathetic, but they are not mistreated by the director, nor made to conform to offensive stereotypes, nor given less attention in their realization because they are of an unimportant class or ethnicity.

There is nothing of racism here, even if white actors made up as other races has been done in a racist way in the past or done for racist reasons. The important thing is how it is handled, and here it is not in denigration of anyone, so it is not racist. Just because I stab a Congressman with a steak knife does not mean you cannot use a steak knife for something innocuous. The mere act is neutral. I found some of the makeup to look ridiculous, and it took me out of the movie, but that was my only complaint with it.

All in all, the movie is a visual feast, full of nuance and careful craftsmanship, but frustrating and ultimately unfulfilling. Its principal problem is that it is a story with themes, and yet it is fashioned as if it were a theme with some stories. That, at any rate, is my opinion, which I alone am responsible for.

3 / 5 stars     

Help Promote Prometheus Unbound by Sharing this Post

Send to Kindle

About the Author

Matthew Bruce Alexander Staff Writer

Matthew is a libertarian living in central Ohio. A graduate of Ohio State University, he majored in Spanish and has published a work of libertarian science-fiction called Wĭthûr Wē.

{ 5 comments… add one }
  • Restore CBD Gummies Review December 19, 2023 @ 3:59 pm | Link

    Great information shared.. really enjoyed reading this post thank you author for sharing this post .. appreciated

    Reply
  • James Costa December 30, 2023 @ 11:30 am | Link

    Here in Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, things are exactly the same

    Reply
  • Volkmerbxc January 4, 2024 @ 5:04 pm | Link

    If you are still looking for an Web dating site that matches your wants, strive free on-line courting at Romanticity. We attempt to not commit to things. Talk about every thing, even the smallest things. Keep away from speaking about appears and talk about common points. He stated it is the identical as walking down the road and judging folks based mostly on their seems to be. It is also great to fulfill individuals face to face by becoming a member of in local actions, signing up for meeting teams, doing volunteering, taking courses, signing up for the gym, or just hanging out at the native coffee store. Moreover they originate from quite a few totally different social and financial teams, therefore do not get apprehensive concerning your low-level of money as being a hurdle on your internet relationship good outcomes – there are an unbelievable variety of women on the market who’d like to satisfy you for just a beautiful time, or perhaps an extended-term relationship having a view to marital life down the monitor. “When are you having children? Nonetheless, it will be unable to tell you which of them stocks are greatest to buy proper now as a result of it is generally unaware of current occasions. It can be laborious to tell with on-line courting, so it’s value gut checking issues together with your folks.

    You’ll find that you would be able to easily apply the content to enhance your online relationship message dialogue. This has led such communities which rely on person modifying of content to promote customers into turning into lively contributors as well as retention of such current members through tasks such as the Wikimedia Account Creation Enchancment Undertaking. If you’re regular web surfers,then you could find hundreds of personal advertisements,what stands one apart is a properly written profile with an interesting high decision picture.However,there are such a lot of free online relationship providers, personal advertisements and free online private relationship websites can be found to your courting needs.A few of the online resource and guide to matchmaking,relationships,love and discovering. [url=https://vk.com/public82343066]is chnlove.com legit[/url] For example, if a girl’s relationship profile says that she actually enjoys her job, works numerous hours and also likes travelling. Transformative Works and Cultures. This will help them to get a good date and lead a happy life! Unknown restaurants are good clues for the best way to catch cheating partner tip-offs. However there are consultants in all places to guide and reduce such probabilities. We squeeze in there and get ready collectively. Whether or not you’re two peas in a pod, two sides of the identical coin or fall into the “opposites attract” category, take this quiz together to get your ultimate couple rating, or take it separately and see how shut you match up.

    Both method, take this quiz to seek out out what food combo you and your vital different are! That could be your couple meals mixture if that is how your associate makes you feel! It is also the best way by way of which you’ll be able to maintain higher communication along with your dream accomplice. Find someone who drives you crazy, however in one of the simplest ways potential. Be with somebody who evolves with you. Your profile will show anything that you want to express about your self, and sure you will see someone who finds something in frequent with you. Your Fb profile boasts 200 buddies. It’s best to write down all your power for a powerful relationship profile. Passing by a town, a woman hit the “Like” button on his profile. Of course, there have been numerous instances where genuine chemistry has developed between two folks, leading to love and companionship, so all said and done on-line courting is right here to stay as a way to date ladies or men by means of the power of internet. You don’t owe your on-line date something, both.

    Classic love stories don’t all the time occur, however they will! A great romantic relationship could be one among life’s purest pleasures. Nobody actually. We each have things we pay for. In your Twitter account, you’ve 60 followers and also you observe 30 people. You possibly can lookup a plumber online after which find customer critiques from people who’ve used him before. Your social community is sizable — more than 300 people and growing on daily basis. On-line social networks take that native community you’ve got and make it world. On LinkedIn, you’ve 50 connections. But have you ever ever wondered if these on-line connections translate to actual life? But it is possible you may need to deal with each other, particularly in case you have youngsters, even after a breakup. Moreover, it is not an excellent playing ground. There’s even a brand new phrase for it — glocalization. Set safety standards for yourself earlier than you even begin. The onset of the Web has made it so easy to obtain data on any subject matter. You just get pleasure from being with them regardless of the setting. Don’t be scared to be your self, as this virtually always results in being original. Being different is sweet, then again, being too unusual is just creepy.

    Reply
  • Qinzcz January 13, 2024 @ 6:27 pm | Link

    6. Get the best providers: Since these websites have a very good variety of members, they are at all times attempting to higher the companies for his or her prospects. EVE On-line has many attention-grabbing properties that emerge from its “sandbox” setting, especially in the areas referred to as “nullsec” which have utterly free-for-all PVP combat. EVE conveniently stores chat logs in a file on disk. Many because of py-eve-chat-mon which I referenced heavily when attempting to figure out the format of the log file and what regular expressions to make use of for parsing. What follows are some brief notes on the right way to parse on-disk EVE logs into a usable format in Frequent Lisp. For my own education, and for the enjoyable of it, I determined to create one thing similar in Common Lisp to swimsuit my private wants. I’ve named the SASL authentication realm after the service that uses it, in this case Qpid (makes sense no?). If you wish to run your digital camera, you will have to hitch our broadcasting service. Hangouts is a free social and communication service that allows you to ship emojis, images and make group video calls. Group date: an activity shared by two or more couples.

    To keep monitor of enemy exercise in Alliance-controlled space, Alliances often have a typical intel-sharing chat channel (think one thing like an IRC channel), the place players put up messages like R1O-GN 3, indicating that three hostile players have been spotted in the system R1O-GN. You could have been with all this work, and you’ve to excel to be paid-for it. So proper now, all you need to do is take action, as you’ve gotten the proper information to decide on the best online dating site that fits you. The researchers have proven how separate clans – perhaps numbering hundreds of animals – will use their very own specific refined sequence of noises. Ed Pierce: Are there any particular tales or poems by Tolkien – both in the home collection or elsewhere – that you think lend themselves to being offered in a preferred assortment (similar to how the Turin material was extracted from Unfinished Tales and elsewhere and presented within the Children of Hurin)? Before heading on the method from being single to a couple, you could counter some basic items and apply them for effective results. Find issues to discuss and ask as many questions as attainable when it is acceptable. •Save your favourite contacts and find them easily.

    You may easily flick thru their profile in an effort to get particulars about his/her likes, [url=https://medium.com/@QpidNetworkReview]qpid[/url] dislikes, interest, hobbies, favourite film, favourite video games and their career. The individual on the receiving end can easily inform you if they’re confused by an incomplete sentence 🤔. Whenever you write lengthy paragraphs, you drive the opposite person to wait. If you happen to pause a deep conversation to contemplate, send a one-phrase “thinking” message to the opposite individual. You may get particular person of your alternative with a continuous course of chatting. System tests could be configured to run skrouterd processes with an arbitrary wrapper. Particularly, when RabbitMQ is an Erlang-based binary expected to run moreover a Java-powered application. A couple of hours later, they haven’t completed it but. They reply two hours later, however you’re in a meeting and reply afterward. Use Slack status messages to communicate what you’re doing with co-employees. We use this type of status suggestions to prioritize our time and keep away from unnecessary interruptions. Breaking them up lets the receiver process your ideas whilst you write and allows them to provide feedback via reactions💡. And whereas we focus on Slack, our recommendations apply to Microsoft Teams in addition to different platforms. If you speak to real ladies online, there are many do’s that a man should persist with, in addition to don’ts that a man has to avoid in female chat rooms if he desires to succeed in a web based relationship with a lady.

    Know your limits, and persist with them! Most of them will truly slow down your web connection, and even after they do give you speeds you did not know existed, they may in all probability cost you an additional fee for the privilege. The information you read is one that I’m sure will give you the needed headstart to choose the perfect online dating sites all around the internet. If the ideas defined above are religiously adopted and utilized in your try to choose the very best online dating site, it’s a certain guess that one will discover one of the best date irrespective of the class you fall into in terms of age, standing, profession and site. In case you see any of the above behaviors, transfer on. Sync and async communication have totally different best practices. In this episode, Captain Picard and Vash are reunited when the Enterprise hosts an archaeology symposium, however their disparate personalities soon have them sparring as an alternative of spooning. There are literally courting sites online.

    Reply
  • Wankej January 21, 2024 @ 5:38 pm | Link

    And whereas virtual gifts do come at a cost, the funding is well worth the while, extra so if you’re trying to break the ice and kickstart a conversation with a beautiful Asian lady. The primary one is to work at an international company-there’s an opportunity that a gorgeous Asian girl will ultimately come and work there, which creates a great opportunity to develop a connection with her. So we’ve ready the most effective choice of first date questions that will help you. The trick shouldn’t be picking the “finest” place but selecting a spot that works for you. Viewers Award for Greatest narrative characteristic, which relies on viewers’ votes. As with a fountain pen, ink leaves the tip of a felt tip pen by capillary motion when writing on a porous surface. A fountain pen nib, unlike the tip of a ballpoint, gel or rollerball pen, has no transferring parts.

    A pen with a refillable reservoir might have a mechanism equivalent to a piston to draw ink from a bottle by way of the nib, or it might require refilling with an eye fixed dropper. A fountain pen uses water-primarily based liquid ink delivered by means of a nib, which is basically a flat piece of metallic with a thin slit extending inwards from the writing tip. This adjustments the writing expertise by lubricating the movement of the tip over the paper. I’m saying the magnificence in relationships is not perfection in the opposite companion: it is sharing a life experience with them. Emily Lek (October 4, 2007), “Magnificence Talk”, The Straits Times, City, Singapore: Singapore Press Holdings, p. There could also be a slight distinction to the way in which they discuss or the way in which they expect males to deal with them however it is nothing that can’t be learned. There were the times when gorgeous, gentle and incredibly feminine Chinese language girls were not even allowed to talk to a foreigner.

    You can too ship digital (and actual) gifts, view videos on profiles, and live chat with beautiful Asian women. Korean ladies for marriage are soulful, sympathetic, but at the same time emotional, typically sizzling-tempered, and [url=https://www.pinterest.com/idateasia/idateasia-com-reviews/]idateasia scam[/url] are the true scorching ladies. It is needed to understand if the profiles are actual. Are Asian brides expensive to marry? There are a couple of secrets that can enable you find a key to success whereas courting Asian girls. It is a great dating platform for single American men who dream of discovering great and loving Asian ladies. Liu Xiang proofread and edited them into the brand new e-book under the title Zhan Guo Ce; it was therefore not written by a single creator at one time. Many Japanese corporations make the book required studying for their key executives. There are 2 ways to get instructions: write a mail and make a call. Upon registration on the website, customers get on the spot access to the profile database. An iPhone scanner software permits customers to drag up product critiques from CozyCot’s website by capturing the barcodes with cameras of their iPhones.

    Moreover, there may be a brand new characteristic known as Flash Chat, which lets you ship pictures, movies, or even audio clips that may disappear with the time. At “LoveFest 2011”, a speed dating event held in Orchard Central (8-9 October 2011), the feature that drew media attention was the truth that the males participated blindfolded they usually have been encouraged to avoid questions associated to age and looks. The net model consists of the additional options of interactivity and media content material. One of the crucial placing options is their pores and skin. Family is vital: One notable trait amongst many Asian cultures is the devotion to household. On subsequent yr’s anniversary, the marketing campaign consisted in a mass shirt donation drive, in assist of the Star Shelter, a short lived refuge for girls and youngsters victims of family violence (underneath the Singapore Council of Ladies Organization). The brothel is reopened and one after the other, the girls slowly return, till Lakshmi is the just one left at the shelter. It also results in a stable and uninterrupted line, for the reason that diffusion of the ink by the paper fills small gaps which may in any other case be left by the ball level.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Comment Policy

Please keep the following in mind when commenting:

  • Real names preferred but not required.
  • If your comment contains several links, your comment may be held up in moderation; please, be patient.
  • Strive for the ideal speech situation: civility, mutual understanding, no eristic debating tactics, no ad hominems.
  • So long as the comments are not overrun by spammers, trolls, and general incivility, registration will not be required to comment.
  • We reserve the right to delete or mark comments as SPAM, and to moderate or ban abusive commenters, at our discretion.

Next Post:

Previous Post:

Support Prometheus Unbound




Donate toward our web hosting bill!




Get 1 FREE Audiobook from Audible with 30;Day FREE Trial Membership


We recommend Scrivener as the best content-generation tool for writers.